Comment List

  • funkyAnims 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    All of V5C8 deserves to be on there imo. There's actual framing in the character arcs taking place. Like how everytime Yang talks about Blake the scene after cuts to Blake, and while Yang is completely hung up on people leaving her (from past experience), Blake has completely moved on from the situation (which actually has relevance in chapter 13 which I'll touch on later).

    Weiss is the one to give the talk to Yang because 1. She's had a horrie unloving family her whole life, and specifically in V4 she learns to cope with that, and 2. Ruby couldn't have said anything, she would've only made things worse considering she was also abandoned by her mom. Also Ruby is socially awkward lol.

    After it shows Weiss giving the talk to Yang, it shows Blake giving the talk to Ilia (honestly I wouldve liked if they settled some of these tensions within the teammates with TRAINING SESSIONS, could've actually shown Ozpin being a mentor), and Ilia would come to understand too.

    Finally, it comes back up again in 13, when Blake sees Yang again for the first time in like a year, and all of those emotions she pushed back for a greater cause (air quotes) come crashing back down on her. Blake serves as a cool foil to Raven. They both want to see their loved ones again, they both feel like they're the only ones strong enough to do what they do, and they have this burden put onto their shoulders only they (and literally one other person, Sun and Vernal) can handle. But it's with how they deal with it that makes the difference. Blake (after getting the talk from Sun) asks for forgiveness…kinda…from Yang. She recognized her mistakes, and it's actually Raven who ends up running away from her own problems, which is some A1 irony. And guess where Raven ran? Back home. BOOOOOOOOM THE PARALLELS THAT WERE PROBABLY UNINTENTIONAL BUT STILL BOOOOOOOOM!

  • loafhero 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    Wow, I really forgot how Ruby used to have a decently defined character back in Vol 1 before being reduced to a plot macguffin spouting generic optimism lines.

  • Crazo9000 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    I'd agree with most of this list, the only thing I'd add is my number 1 scene, Weiss and Yangs hug at the end of Volume 5 Episode 4. Its the first time we see two of the main 4 together after a whole volume apart, and their reactions leading into and during the hug are perfect for what they've been through in volume 4, and show how much they've changed since volume 1. Yang is no longer the fun, wisecracking person she was before, she's scared, feels lonely and betrayed, and isn't quite sure how to talk to people anymore. She turns to Weiss, about to apologise, unsure of herself. Then Weiss throws herself onto her. Weiss has been alone, taken by her abusive father, separated from her friends that had made her a better person and who actually cared about her. She's been held prisoner by both her father and now bandits, and has really seen how shit her old life was and how good she had it with team RWBY, so she tells Yang how much she missed her; she's just glad to have a friend again. Yang, meanwhile, isn't sure how to reciprocate. You can see it on her face, she's uncomfortable and she doesn't know how to react. But hearing Weiss say that, puts to rest Yangs fears of being abandoned again, at least partially, and she is able to return the hug.
    Now I wouldn't be surprised if none of that was intentional, but I fucking love that scene

  • Kushrada 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    "Ruby needs to make the most of the time with her friends because they'll end up dead in a ditch long before her." I love this line, not because I hate Ruby but because I love her. Or at least that was one aspect of Ruby I loved before it was sidelined for…about anything else.
    Penny dies and this galvanizes Ruby to protect Pyrrha(the person who killed Penny physically). Which may have lead to Ruby's emotional breakdown witnessing Pyrrha then die(her additional failure to protect a person she tried to protect). Rubys coming to terms with both deaths is cruelly amounted to her one talk with Oscar saying that they are both dead and she wished she knew them both more. I've seen a lot of people nitpick that scene saying that the talk should have happened with Jaune instead and while I agree that talk should still happen I still value Oscar as the recipient of Ruby's talk due to him being a neutral third party.

    It reminds me of a scene from an Evangelion manga where shinji is talking about the death of one of his friends to Kaworu(Kaworu being antagonistic to this character before their death) and Kaworu asking why Shinji feels so comfortable talking about someone shinji knows Kaworu didn't like to which Shinji reasons and I am paraphrasing "Its because you are detached from the loss and wont make me feel worst than the people who I know that were also close to them." If it were Jaune who Ruby was having this conversation with would she had admitted to not really knowing Pyrrha? I wouldn't think so. Its also nice that Oz just stood by and let Ruby grieve with out interrupting a rather personal conversation even though there might have been a ton of advice he could have offered her.

  • BloodRose Reaper 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    " Bitch? She's your sister! WTf are you doing? "
    The B-E-S-T moment of this video lol

  • DivinePhoenix901 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    I just noticed, look at 15:40, then look at Weiss rapier hilt… try not to get a dirty mind…

  • Troy 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    my fav scence was when adam cut yangs arm off

  • jack McGwire 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    I love your channel 😘

  • Alex Langrock 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSk-ldXKGZE&feature=youtube Just take a look at this, then come to your own conclusions
    Edit: Just tell me what you think about all of this.

  • Karan Malun 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    I would have put Yang's scenes from burning the candle and the one when she opens to Weiss in episode 8 volume 5, althought I can get why they didn't make the cut since they both involve Blake aka poorly-written-bipolar-cat.

  • Filip Zemiakovic 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    Pretty good choice of scenes.

    My personal favorite is probably the Nevermore fight just cause I just love the animation on that. Another favorite of mine is the Roman death scene too.

    Though on that thing with Yang's friends. First time when I saw RWBY I was kind of hoping the guys from Team CRDL would turn out to be her friends. Not Cardin, but maybe the rest. I mean, they are portrayed as douchebags, but then again, Yang destroyed a whole night club just cause she didn't find what she was looking for. Dunno, seems like a waste of characters with potential to me.

    I mean, how refreshing would it be if someone on Team CRDL was a Faunus and we got to see how they react to it. Maybe the Faunus from Team CRDL would at first be ignored by Cardin, but being friends with the rest of the team would eventually earn him Cardin's respect and change how he views the Faunus.

    My main problem with the show is that it's antagonists are written as if they're all just evil for the sake of being evil without any redeeming qualities (Cinder, Adam, Cardin and so on).

  • saramations 29 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    Can't forget the scene where Tyrian calls Ruby a bitch.

  • dracocrusher 30 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    Number 8? Really? Okay, so Weiss telling off one douchebag. Fine, I guess. But this entire charity scene as a whole has to be one of the dumbest moments Weiss has ever been a part of. Seriously, think about this in context! These people are here specifically to give money to save people's lives. Douchebags or not, they are actively there to do much-needed good in the world, but the moment anyone speaks their horrible opinion, Weiss is just immediately like "No, you don't get to have offensive thoughts, stop helping us and get out of here or I will accidentally nearly murder you and be praised for it!"

    I mean, seriously… what the fuck even?! This is the type of bullshit a villain would do! This is character destroying! All this does is tell me that Weiss hasn't changed a bit, she's still the same self-entitled brat she used to be because she still hasn't learned to restrain herself or put others above herself. And don't get me wrong, that could work if the series actually acknowledged that this behavior is a problem and that she needs to better herself. But the series isn't interested in that at all and then it later asks us to feel bad for Weiss, to feel BAD for this selfish, self-entitled, controlling, near-murdering asshole, when she's finally forced to take consequences for her attempted assault!

    I'm sorry, RWBY, but fuck you, I'm not buying it! Weiss is absolutely the villain in this situation! She's the one actively scaring people away from helping those in need and I don't see how anyone could ever respect someone like that!

  • Kenji 30 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    My favorite part? The Credits where they misspelled Oscar's last name. *EDIT* HOORAY SENPAI NOTICED ME!!

  • Jeff Hughes 30 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    I'm surprised Murder of Birds are Patrons to you guys.

  • Michael Massari 31 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    When Jaune gets the K.I.S.S. but then Phyrra dies ;( emotional but hits you even harder when Jaunes training alone in V4 EP2

  • Alexei Strife 31 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    Yeah, but, how do you feel about this video?

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSk-ldXKGZE

  • Mia Icefyre 31 / 05 / 2018 Reply

    Wow, you have an Ozpin scene right at the top. From what I gathered from the few vids I’d seen I didn’t think you liked him very much 🙂

  • Brandon B 01 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    I think you like Weiss

  • Anthoneka King 01 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    Wait fatmanfalling have list of good things for rwby thank god

  • TheRockhound119 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    Ruby versus Torchwick and Neo was my favourite scene in the show to date due to it being pure gold. Also, the "You have Silver Eyes" Did come up, though it was only mentioned. Oscar said it when he first saw Ruby.

  • ThatOneGuy Q23 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    The Ruby vs Neo and Torchwick scene game me chills

  • York 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    My favorite scene is Yang and Raven interacting…Cause Raven is my favorite character (Not just by appearance or voice. I like her personality). I also don't analyze shows when i watch them since most people that do that end up mainly talking about things they hate…But hey, that's just me.
    ALSO, i have a question! Why did Yang want to be a huntress. I would like to know since i've forgotten or we haven't seen.

  • Xavier Hege 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    Tyrian getting punched in the face. That was such a reality check for the fucker.

  • Rebecca Pettersson 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    That about Tai being Yangs teacher… eehhh. I'm sure he was not the ONLY teacher there sooo you can't just jump the gun and give Tai all the responsibility there. And I think I'm seeing your way of criticizing and your humor wrong 'cause well it sounds like you hate RWBY with a passion!! I think it would help you make your point better if you present it in less of a "this is shit" kind of way and rephrase in a better way. And if you hate it that's ok but why are you making content on it? And it really does not seem like you are trying to help the show, you are just saying what YOU think is bad, YOUR OPINIONS, that some but not all agree with. And you are not even giving neutral advice about how to make it better. But then again it could just be me!

  • Brycen Lanager 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    I will disagree with Fatman on one point, not about the list but his criticism of the Nevermore and Deathstalker fight.
    I thought it was really clear why they abandoned the plan to run. The Nevermore overtook them at a choke point (flying is faster than running) and were then blocked in by the Death-stalker. Granted it would have been nice to have a throwaway line to say that but I thought it was pretty clear.

  • ray eittastay 03 / 06 / 2018 Reply

    I came here to watch people fight about Rwby and trying to force their opinions on others. You know who you are…

Leave a Reply